Quick answer
How does the EU DSA differ from the DMCA for hosting?
The DMCA is a US copyright procedure that rewards fast removal; the EU Digital Services Act covers all illegal content and requires reasoned decisions. IronKVM runs VPS in 2 EU countries, where the DSA has applied since 17 February 2024, and in Moldova, where it does not apply. DMCA notices get no action.
In brief
- Scope: DMCA section 512 covers copyright only; the DSA covers any content illegal under EU or member-state law.
- Notice: both require a precise location and a good-faith statement; the DSA also wants an explanation of why the content is illegal.
- Customer rights: the DMCA offers a counter-notice; the DSA requires a statement of reasons and redress options.
- Where: the DSA binds hosting services in the EU, so IronKVM's Amsterdam and Bucharest servers, not Chisinau.
How do the two systems compare point by point?
| Point | DMCA, 17 U.S.C. § 512 | Digital Services Act, Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 |
|---|---|---|
| In force | Enacted 28 October 1998 | Applies from 17 February 2024 (Article 93) |
| Content covered | Copyright infringement | Any illegal content under EU or member-state law (Article 3(h)) |
| Host's liability | Safe harbor if it removes expeditiously after a valid notice | Not liable without actual knowledge; must act expeditiously once aware (Article 6) |
| What a notice must hold | Signature, the work, the material and its location, contact, good-faith and accuracy statements | Reasons why the content is illegal, exact location such as a URL, name and email, good-faith statement (Article 16(2)) |
| Host's duty to the sender | None set for the decision | Confirm receipt and give the decision with redress options (Article 16(4) and (5)) |
| Host's duty to the customer | Notify of the removal; restore 10 to 14 business days after a counter-notice | Clear and specific statement of reasons for any restriction (Article 17) |
| General monitoring | Not required (section 512(m)) | Not allowed as a general obligation (Article 8) |
| Abuse of the system | Damages for knowing misrepresentation (section 512(f)) | Online platforms suspend frequent senders of manifestly unfounded notices (Article 23); not set for other hosts |
Which content does each law cover?
Section 512 deals with copyright alone; the Digital Services Act deals with every kind of illegal content. Under Article 3(h) of the DSA, illegal content is any information that does not comply with EU law or with the law of a member state.
That makes the DSA wider and more local at the same time. A notice under it must point to a breach of EU law or of a member state's law. A DMCA notice points to US copyright law.
For a host in Amsterdam or Bucharest, copyright claims under Dutch or Romanian law reach it through the DSA notice system and through national courts. The country pages describe those national rules.
Who decides, and how fast?
Under the DMCA the host removes first; under the DSA the host must decide in a timely, diligent, non-arbitrary and objective manner. The DMCA sets one clear clock: 10 to 14 business days before restoring material after a counter-notice.
The DSA sets no fixed number of days in Article 16. It asks for diligence, and a notice counts as actual knowledge when a diligent host can see the illegality without a detailed legal examination (Article 16(3)). Removal then must follow expeditiously under Article 6.
The DSA also gives national authorities direct tools. Articles 9 and 10 cover orders from judicial or administrative authorities to act against content or to provide information.
Who supervises hosts under the DSA?
Each EU country names a Digital Services Coordinator. In the Netherlands, the Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM) became competent on 4 February 2025, and it names web hosting as a focus area. In Romania, Law No. 50/2024 designated ANCOM, published in the Official Journal no. 232 of 19 March 2024.
ANCOM's DSA page says other authorities, each supervising its own sector, may act against specific illegal content.
Moldova is outside the EU, so the DSA does not apply there. The Moldova page gives its own rules.
What does this mean for an IronKVM customer?
A US DMCA notice changes nothing on an IronKVM server; the law of the server's country still applies in full. IronKVM takes no action on DMCA takedown notices or on other foreign copyright notices: the VPS stays online and no customer data is handed over because of such a notice. Ignoring DMCA notices does not make illegal content acceptable. What runs on an IronKVM VPS must be legal in the country of its datacenter.
According to IronKVM's survey of 16 November 2026, 22 hosts sold VPS in the Netherlands, 10 in Romania and 3 in Moldova. Only 3 of the Dutch hosts and 2 of the Romanian hosts published a DMCA ignored policy.
The Netherlands and Romania comparison weighs the two EU options. The price is the same in all three countries: Anvil costs $15.00 a month on 12 months.
DSA and DMCA: questions
Does the DSA apply to a VPS host?
Yes, in the EU. A VPS host stores information for its customers, which makes it a hosting service. Articles 6 and 16 apply to hosting services from 17 February 2024.
Can a sender stay unnamed in a DSA notice?
A DSA notice should carry the sender's name and email, under Article 16(2)(c). The exception is information involving child sexual abuse offences under Directive 2011/93/EU.
Does the DSA have a counter-notice like the DMCA?
Not in the same form. Article 17 gives the customer a statement of reasons for any restriction, including the redress available.
Does a DMCA notice count as a DSA notice?
The DSA asks for an explanation of why content is illegal under EU or member-state law. A DMCA notice is written under US law. How a specific notice is treated depends on its content.
Verdict
- The DMCA is narrow and fast; the DSA is broad and reasoned. Hosts in the Netherlands and Romania answer to the DSA, not to section 512.
- IronKVM takes no action on DMCA notices in all three countries, keeps content legal under local law, and charges the same price everywhere.
Sources (5)
- Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 (Digital Services Act) — Publications Office of the European Union (read 2026-11-16)
- 17 U.S. Code § 512 — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (read 2026-11-16)
- Public Law 105-304: Digital Millennium Copyright Act — U.S. Government Publishing Office (read 2026-11-16)
- ACM vanaf nu bevoegd toezicht te houden op de Digital Services Act — Autoriteit Consument & Markt (published 2025-02-03, read 2026-11-16)
- Digital services — ANCOM (read 2026-11-16)
A VPS under local law, not US notices
Amsterdam, Bucharest or Chisinau, one price, paid in crypto.